The life of an insurance claim (podcast) | The Dental Grind

The Dental Grind podcastSeason 1, episode 219 min

The life of an insurance claim

A crown isn't paid when you seat it. Ryan Smith, DDS walks one insurance claim from verification to the bank, with real numbers from his own offices, and shows where the money gets stuck.

Companion piece: You did the crown. Where's the money?

In this episode

  • The second clock: a claim is a promise, and slow claims tie up cash (at $100,000 a month in claims, every extra 15 days is about $50,000 waiting)
  • Step one, verification: the questions to answer before the patient sits down
  • Step two, the claim: what the reviewer actually sees, and why a narrative and an intraoral photo on every crown help
  • Sending claims the same day, and what a claim sent 112 days late looks like
  • Reading the EOB: downcoding, bundling, and the line with no money next to it
  • Denials, appeals and a one- or two-strike rule before the balance goes to the patient
  • Virtual cards and how to opt out
  • Collecting the patient’s part at the visit, with an estimate given when treatment is scheduled
  • How long insurers are allowed to take in Washington and Oregon
  • Why annual maximums haven’t kept up since 1997

Read the numbers in the newsletter: You did the crown. Where’s the money?

Transcript

Last episode we talked about the crown clock, how long a crown sits in your chair. This week there is a second clock, and it starts the minute the patient gets up. You seat the crown on a Tuesday. The patient walks out happy. And the money? Well, it’s not in your account. It’s in a claim. And that claim has to make it through about seven handoffs before a single dollar shows up. In one of my offices, the average claim takes about 21 days to get paid. I’d like to get that down to about 14. The good insurance companies pay in about a week. It’s the claims that drag out that pull the average up. And every one of those handoffs is a place where it can stall. Today I’m going to walk one claim from the front desk to the bank and show you every place that it can get stuck. Here’s why this matters. Even if you never touch a claim yourself. For most practices, insurance is the biggest single source of money coming in. That means most of what you produce today

doesn’t turn into cash today. It turns into a promise. And a promise is only worth what it pays and when. So let me put a number on that. Say an office sends $100,000 a month in claims. If those claims take 30 days to pay, about $100,000 is sitting out there at any moment waiting. If they take 45 days, it’s about $150,000. Same dentistry, same fees, $50,000 more dollars of your money sitting in someone else’s bank account. This is the Dental Grind. I’m Ryan Smith DDS. I run dental practices and every week I open up my numbers and show you how I work through them. That’s money you can’t use to make payroll, pay the lab or pay yourself. And the longer a claim sits, the less likely it gets paid at all. So let’s follow one. A crown on a patient with a regular PPO plan

through work. The claim starts before the patient ever shows up. It starts with verification. Somebody at the front desk has to look at the patient’s plan and answer a handful of questions. Is the plan active? What’s the annual maximum and how much of it is used? What’s the deductible? How often they will pay for a crown on the same tooth? And is there a waiting period? Is there a missing tooth clause? And does the plan downgrade certain things like paying a posterior composite as if it were an amalgam? This is the first place a claim stalls and most people don’t even think of it as part of the claim. If you get the benefits wrong, everything downstream is wrong. Your estimate to the patient is wrong. What you collect at the visit is wrong. And three weeks later, you’re sending the patient a bill that they didn’t expect. It’s not just you. In a survey of more than 160 dental billing people this year, 71% said real time insurance verification was one of their top

challenges. It’s slow, the payer websites are all different and the phone calls take forever. In my offices, we typically check eligibility a couple of days ahead. When we’re doing a full verification, we may go a little farther ahead than that. The rule I’d give anybody is verify before the visit, not at the visit. If you find out at check-in that that plan turned last month, you’ve already lost that appointment potentially. Step two happens in the chair and it’s the part that we as dentists actually control. The claim is only as good as the chart. The insurance company never sees the patient. It sees a code, an x-ray, maybe a photo, and a sentence or two of a narrative. That’s it. That’s all they have to decide whether to pay you. For a crown, that means a current x-ray that shows why the tooth needs it, an intraoral photo of the fracture or the broken down filling. If the x-ray doesn’t tell the story, you need that image. A narrative that says what’s wrong in plain words. Fractured cusp, recurrent decay and

or large filling, whatever it is. If the documentation doesn’t show the need, the claim comes back. Not because the dentistry was wrong but because a reviewer looking at it at one image couldn’t see what you saw. In one of my offices, crowns get paid in about 20 days and about one crown in 15 comes back paid at zero. In my offices, every crown claim goes out with a narrative but we don’t typically put a photo on there. We probably should. An intraoral photo along with the x-ray on every crown is just good standard practice. Here’s the habit that fixes most of this. Write the note and take the image while the patient is still in the chair. Not at the end of the day. Not at the end of the week. You will never remember it better than you do right then. Step three, the claim gets coded and sent. Every procedure, of course, has a CDT code and the code has to match what’s in the chart. If the note says a porcelain fused the high noble

crown and the code says something else, that’s a problem. If you did a build-up and didn’t document why the tooth needed one, expect that line to come back. And then it has to go out fast. Here’s a little history. In 1997, a dentist named Rick Kushner, who ran a big group of low-fee offices in Colorado, told his readers to file claims by hand the same day. By hand. On paper. That same day. Today, almost every claim goes out electronically through a clearinghouse, and it can go that same afternoon. But plenty of offices still batch claims, sending them once a week or waiting until later on. Every day a claim sits in your desk is a day added to the clock and the insurance company didn’t even get it yet. I can show you what this costs. In one of my offices, 86% of claims go out the same day as the visit and 95% within three days. That office gets paid about three weeks or so after the visit. Send it the day you do

the work. Attachments and everything. Step four is the one that almost nobody understands, the clearinghouse. A clearinghouse is the middleman between your software and the insurance company. It takes your claim, checks it for obvious errors, and passes it along. And here’s the important part. There’s a difference between a rejection and a denial. A rejection means the claim never got on the door. A wrong member ID, a missing date of birth, a provider number that doesn’t match. The insurance company never looked at it. It’s not in their system. Nothing is happening on it at all. A denial means they looked at it and said no. The danger with rejections is that they’re quiet. Somebody has to check the clearinghouse report and fix them. If nobody does, that claim just sits there. You think it’s at the insurance company. The insurance company has never even heard of it. 30 days later, somebody calls to check on it and finds out it was never received. So somebody in your office should own that report every single day. Step five is where the insurance company

actually decides. They call it adjudication. This is where most of the denials happen. The reviewer or more and more often a computer checks your claim against the plan’s rules. Is it within the frequency limit? Is there enough documentation for medical necessity? Is this a procedure the plan bundles with something else? Does the plan pay a lesser alternative? It’s getting harder. In that same survey this year, almost 80% of practices said they’ve seen more denials or more scrutiny from payers in the past 12 months. And most of them blamed exactly these things. Frequency limits and how the payer interprets medical necessity. And one of my offices, about one claim in 10, comes back the first time with at least one procedure paid at zero. About 2% come back with nothing paid at all. Here’s what I want you to understand about a denial. A denial is not a final answer. It’s a request for a better claim. Some

of them are wrong and an appeal in writing will just fix it. Some of them are right and the plan just doesn’t cover it. Either way somebody in your office has to read everyone and decide what to do with it. And there’s one more thing that happens here that drives dentists crazy and that’s recoupment. The plan pays you and then months later decides it shouldn’t have and takes the money back out of a future check. Some states are finally putting limits on that. Indiana cut its window to 180 days. Connecticut went to 12 months. Oregon set 18 months this year. Here’s one from one of my offices. The work got done but the claim didn’t go out until 112 days after the visit. It’s been sitting unpaid for about eight months since. Three thousand four hundred and sixteen dollars billed. Zero collected almost a year after the work and a claim sent that late can run into the plans filing deadline so that money may actually

never come in. Step six the money actually moves. The insurance company pays one of three ways. A paper check in the mail, a direct deposit which is probably what you want, or a virtual credit card. The last one is sneaky. The payment shows up as a card number and when you run it the card processor takes a fee. You just did the crown at a discounted PPO fee and now you’re paying a few percent more to receive the money. Some states are stepping in here too. Georgia and Louisiana now require the insurance company to get your okay before paying you in a way that cost you a fee. I hate virtual credit cards. They’re a way for the insurance companies to make more money off of you. Opt out of every one of them and here’s what’s done. We’ll opt out in one of the offices and we’ll be getting paid the normal way and then all of a sudden one of them switches back to virtual cards again. It’s a dirty tactic so keep watching out for it. Along with the money comes the EOB of the explanation of benefits. It tells you what you billed, what they allowed, what

they paid, and what you have to write off and then also what the patient owes. Don’t just file it. Read it, check the payment against your contracted fee and look for down-coding where they paid for a cheaper procedure than the one you did. Look for bundling where they rolled two things into one and paid for only one. A line with no money next to it is your tell. Then somebody has

to post the payment correctly in your software so the patient’s balance is right. If the posting is wrong, the patient gets the wrong bill and now you have an unhappy patient over a mistake that wasn’t theirs. Step seven is the patient share. On a crown, most PPO plans pay around half after the deductible so the patient owes a real amount. The question is when you collect it. Kushner had a rule back in the 90s, your receivables should sit with the insurance companies not with your patients. The insurance company is going to pay eventually. The patient who walked out without paying might not. In some of my offices right now, patients carry about half or so what is owed. Kushner’s rule makes sense. You want the insurance company paying, not the patient, but one of the bigger problems in my practices is the opposite. We don’t turn the balance over to the patient soon enough. We let it drag on for months. I think it’s smarter to have a one strike or maybe a two strike policy. If a claim comes

back denied and you can see the fix easily, great, just resubmit it. But if the denial is vague and you can’t see the fix, turn it over to the patient sooner. It’s just better communication and it’s not your job to spend six to eight months on collecting on something the patient is responsible for. It’s not fun to do but it is probably the right business decision. That means collecting the patient’s estimated share at the visit, not sending a statement later. Every statement that you mail costs you money to send and it gets you paid slower, if even at all. This is exactly why step one matters so much. If your verification was right, your estimate is right and you collect the right amount at the visit. If your verification was wrong, you either collected too little and you’re chasing the patient or you collected too much and you’re writing a refund. In one of my offices, insurers paid about 90% of what we estimated and about four out of five procedures landed somewhere within 10% of the estimate. So when the estimate misses, it usually

misses the same way. The patient owes a little more than we quoted. For crowns, I collect the patient’s share for the whole crown at the appointment before we start. Not half of the prep and not half of the seat. A small percentage of patients just won’t come back and once you prep a tooth, you have to finish it. Legally, you have to finish that tooth. So if they haven’t paid, you’re only hurting yourself. A lot of front desks don’t collect at the visit because they don’t know what to say. It feels awkward. So here’s a simple way to say it. Your words don’t matter much. The idea does. When the treatment is scheduled, not at checkout, your insurance is estimated to cover about this much. Your part is estimated at this much. And we’ll take that the day of your appointment. If your insurance pays more than we expect, we’ll send you the refund right away. That’s it. Three things

what insurance should pay, what you owe and when, and what happens if the insurance is off. Notice it happens when the appointment gets made, not when the patient is standing at the counter with their coat on. Nobody likes a surprise at checkout. If they heard the number a week ago, paying it on the day isn’t a surprise. It’s just their plan. And notice the refund promise. That one sentence takes away most of the worry because the patient knows you’re not trying to keep their money. You’re just not waiting six weeks to find out. Now how long is the insurance company allowed to take? Well, it depends on where you are and what kind of a plan it is. Here in the Northwest, Washington’s rule is that 95% of claims need to get paid within 30 days and 95% of all claims get paid or denied within 60. If a clean claim sits more than 61 days, the insurer can owe interest 1% a month. Oregon passed a law this year that says a clean claim has to be paid or denied within 45

days. Oregon also joined the states that make insurers pay the dentist directly when the patient asks, even if you’re out of network. That’s 30 states now total. But notice the word clean. A clean claim is one with nothing missing and nothing wrong. Everything we just talked about, the verification, the documentation, the right code, the attachments, it’s what makes a claim clean. A claim that’s missing an x-ray isn’t clean and the clock doesn’t really start. And here’s the catch. A lot of patients get their dental benefits through a self-funded employer plan. Those plans argue that a federal law called ERISA means state dental laws don’t apply to them. So the prompt pay rule, the recoupment limit, the direct pay rule, they may not cover that patient at all. And you usually can’t tell from the insurance card. The ADA is pushing Congress on this right now. Their letter to the Senate Finance Committee this fall asked to let states apply their

dental protections to self-funded plans too. They point out states have passed about 400 dental insurance reforms. And a lot of them just don’t reach those plans.

One more number before we wrap up because it ties all this together. In 1997 Kushner wrote that $1,000 annual maximum quote, takes care of one tooth. And that was almost 30 years ago. The $1,000 max was set about 40 years ago. Today according to the ADA about 48% of in network plans have a maximum somewhere between $1,500 and $2,500. Another third are still between $1,000 and $1,500. Meanwhile, think about what a crown cost now compared to the 90s. The interesting part is only about three and a half percent of patients actually hit the typical maximum in a year. So for most patients, the max isn’t what limits the claim. The rules are the frequencies, the downgrades, the waiting periods, which is why step one verification matters so much. My take is annual maximums today in general are garbage. They are nowhere near what a patient needs to keep

their mouth healthy. If you’re a year two associate, here’s why you should care about this process. You’ll probably never even have to run. If you’re paid on collections, every denied claim and every claim that never got sent is money out of your check, not the owners yours. It shows up weeks later, so you won’t connect it to the crown that you did. So ask two questions at your office. First, how does a denied claim affect what I get paid and who follows up on it? Second, can I see my own collections, not just my production? If there’s a big gap between what you produce and what gets collected, the claim process is a good place to look. And the part you do control is step two, your notes, your x-rays, your photos, your narratives make every claim you touch a clean one. So here’s your homework. Pull your insurance aging report. Every practice management system has one. Count how many claims are older than 30 days and how many are older

than 60. Then pick the five oldest claims and find that exactly where each one is stuck. Was it rejected at the clearinghouse and nobody saw it, waiting on an x-ray, denied and nobody appealed, paid on a virtual credit card that nobody ran? Write down the step where each one stalled. I bet you’ll see the same step more than once. That’s the one to fix first. When you’ve done it, hit reply on the newsletter and tell me two numbers. How many days your claims take to get paid on average and what share of them are older than 60 days? I want to see how wide that spread is from office to office. Next week, the PPO math, nobody shows you at signing, write offs, fee schedules that never move and how to tell which plans are actually costing. That’s the grind for this week. The numbers from today’s episode and a few more are in the newsletter. It’s free at grind.dental. If this one helped, send it to a classmate or the associate down the hall. I’m Ryan Smith DDS. That’s my name on YouTube and

everywhere else. I’ll see you next Monday.

Get the Grind every Monday

One part of the practice per issue, explained with real numbers, plus each new podcast episode the day it's out.